Here are the current results for top tracks. 

Not very meaningful, but a list nonetheless. The track votes are for appearances on specific albums as you can see.

Track Votes
Merlin The Magician from The Myths & Legends of King Arthur & The Knights of the Round Table 73
Judas Iscariot from Rick Wakeman's Criminal Record 60
Catherine of Aragon from The Six Wives of Henry VIII 42
Catherine Howard from The Six Wives of Henry VIII 38
The Last Battle from The Myths & Legends of King Arthur & The Knights of the Round Table 36
Arthur from The Myths & Legends of King Arthur & The Knights of the Round Table 34
Anne Boleyn from The Six Wives of Henry VIII 33
Statue of Justice from Rick Wakeman's Criminal Record 32
The Battle from Journey to the Centre of the Earth 31
Music Reincarnate - The Maker from No Earthly Connection 29
The Journey from Journey to the Centre of the Earth 29
Jane Seymour from The Six Wives of Henry VIII 24
Guinevere from The Myths & Legends of King Arthur & The Knights of the Round Table 22
Catherine Parr from The Six Wives of Henry VIII 20
Overture from 1984 19
The Prisoner from No Earthly Connection 18
Anne of Cleves from The Six Wives of Henry VIII 17
Chamber of Horrors from Rick Wakeman's Criminal Record 15
White Rock from White Rock 15
Birdman of Alcatraz from Rick Wakeman's Criminal Record 14
Music Reincarnate - The Warning from No Earthly Connection 14
Sir Lancelot and the Black Knight from The Myths & Legends of King Arthur & The Knights of the Round Table 13
Ice Run from White Rock 11
Julia from 1984 10
The Dance Of A Thousand Lights from Return To The Centre Of The Earth 10
The Forest from Journey to the Centre of the Earth 10
Buried Alive from Return To The Centre Of The Earth 9
The Lost Cycle from No Earthly Connection 9
Recollection from Journey to the Centre of the Earth 8
The Hymn from 1984 8
1984 from 1984 7
After The Ball from White Rock 7
Caesarea from Wakeman with Wakeman 7
Music Reincarnate - The Realisation from No Earthly Connection 7
Elegy (Grays) from Cost of Living 6
Music Reincarnate - The Spaceman from No Earthly Connection 6
Never Is A Long, Long Time from Return To The Centre Of The Earth 6
Searching For Gold from White Rock 6
Sir Galahad from The Myths & Legends of King Arthur & The Knights of the Round Table 5
The End Of The Return from Return To The Centre Of The Earth 5
The Room (Brainwash) from 1984 5
After Prayers from Softsword 4
I Can Hear You from Can You Hear Me? 4
Sea Horses from Rhapsodies 4
The Kill from Return To The Centre Of The Earth 4
Catherine Howard from The Piano Album 3
Crime of Passion from Rick Wakeman's Criminal Record 3
Forgotten Memories from 1984 3
Gone But Not Forgotten from Cost of Living 3
Journey to the Centre of the Earth from Classic Tracks 3
Lady of the Lake from The Myths & Legends of King Arthur & The Knights of the Round Table 3
Montezuma's Revenge from White Rock 3
Music Reincarnate - The Reaper from No Earthly Connection 3
Rhapsody in Blue from Rhapsodies 3
Sorry from 1984 3
Birdman of Alcatraz from Rick Wakeman Live in Concert 2000 CD 2
Cathedral of the Sky from Out There 2
Children of Chernobyl from Rick Wakeman Live in Concert 2000 CD 2
Eleanor Rigby from Tribute 2
Forward Past from 2000AD Into The Future 2
Ghost of a Rock'n'Roll Star from Silent Nights 2
Gone But Not Forgotten from The Classical Connection 2
Gone But Not Forgotten from The Piano Album 2
Harbour Lights from Sea Airs 2
It's a Lovely Life from Crimes of Passion 2
Jane Seymour from Rick Wakeman Live in Concert 2000 CD 2
Magna Charter from Softsword 2
Mausoleum at Halicarnassus from The Seven Wonders of the World 2
Merlin the Magician from Rick Wakeman Live in Concert 2000 CD 2
Merlin The Magician from The Piano Album 2
Merlin The Magician from The Classical Connection 2
Nine Ice Groove from White Rock II 2
Out There from Out There 2
Robot Man from 1984 2
Sea Horses from Rick Wakeman's Greatest Hits 2
Sir Lancelot and the Black Knight from Live On The Test 2
Still Waters Run Deep from Return To The Centre Of The Earth 2
The Breathalyser from Rick Wakeman's Criminal Record 2
The Mission from Out There 2
Tommaso Aniello (Masaniello) from Black Knights at the Court of Ferdinand IV 2
Wondrous Stories from Two Sides of Yes 2
1984 Overture from The Classical Connection 1
A Wish To Fly from The Wizard And The Forest Of All Dreams 1
Abide With Me from Morning Has Broken 1
Africa East from African Bach 1
African Bach from African Bach 1
Anne Boleyn (2009) from The Six Wives of Henry VIII Live at Hampton Court Palace 1
Anthem from African Bach 1
Arthur from Recollections - The Very Best of Rick Wakeman 1
Awaken from The Yes Piano Variations 1
Can You Smell Burning? from Retro 1
Catherine Howard/Catherine of Aragon from Rick Wakeman Live in Concert 2000 CD 1
Catherine Parr from Rick Wakeman In Concert 1
Childhood Dreams from The Wizard And The Forest Of All Dreams 1
Close To The Edge from Two Sides of Yes 1
Dance Of The Elves from Romance of the Victorian Age 1
Dandelion Dreams from Country Airs (Original) 1
Dark Maybe '80 from Rock n Roll Prophet 1
Do You Believe In Fairies? from Rock n Roll Prophet 1
Don't Fly Away from Softsword 1
Eleanor Rigby from The Classical Connection 2 1
Elgin Mansions from Silent Nights 1
Elizabethan Rock from Time Machine 1
Freefall from Themes 1
Half Holiday from Rhapsodies 1
Heather Carpets from Country Airs (Original) 1
Heaven from Phantom Power 1
Hills Of The North, Rejoice from Morning Has Broken 1
Homage To The Doctor from Retro 1
If Only from Romance of the Victorian Age 1
Into The Future from 2000AD Into The Future 1
Is Anybody There? from Return To The Centre Of The Earth 1
Jerusalem from Morning Has Broken 1
Jiggajig from Wakeman with Wakeman 1
Journey to the Centre of the Earth from Out of the Blue 1
Journey to the Centre of the Earth from Wakeman with Wakeman - The Official Bootleg 1
Lax'x from White Rock 1
Lure of the Wild from Wakeman with Wakeman 1
March of the Gladiators from Rhapsodies 1
Merlin The Magician from Rick Wakeman In Concert 1
Moment in Time from Vignettes 1
Mr Slow from Return To The Centre Of The Earth 1
Music of Love from Out There 1
Nina (Rick's wife) from The Family Album 1
No Earthly Connection/The Prisoner from Out of the Blue 1
Number 10 from No Expense Spared 1
Oriental Iceman from White Rock II 1
Orpheus Song from Lisztomania 1
Overture from Journey to the Centre of the Earth 1
Pachelbel Canon in D from Rick Wakeman Live in Concert 2000 CD 1
Rienzi/Chopsticks Fantasia from Lisztomania 1
Rock Pursuit from Phantom Power 1
Sagittarius from Zodiaque 1
Shakespeare Run from Cost of Living 1
Siberian Khatru from Rick Wakeman's Greatest Hits 1
Slaveman from Time Machine 1
St Michael's Isle from The Piano Album 1
St Michael's Isle from The Heritage Suite 1
Starship Trooper from Fields of Green 1
Statue of Justice from Recollections - The Very Best of Rick Wakeman 1
Stella Bianca from Stella Bianca alla corte de Re Ferdinando 1
Summertime from Rhapsodies 1
Tell 'Em All You Know from Silent Nights 1
Temperament of Mind from Voyage 1
The Barber of Wigan from Treasure Chest Volume 4 - Almost Classical 1
The Chapel By Candlelight from Chronicles of Man 1
The Cycle of Life from Preludes to a Century 1
The Da Vinci Variations from Rick Wakeman at Lincoln Cathedral 1
The Day After The Fair from The Family Album 1
The Journey/Recollection (excerpt) from Recollections - The Very Best of Rick Wakeman 1
The Lone Sailor from Sea Airs 1
The Marie Celeste from Sea Airs 1
The Meeting from The Piano Album 1
The Mermaid from Sea Airs 1
The Opening Line from Silent Nights 1
The Pulse from Rhapsodies 1
The Recollection/Dance of a Thousand Lights from Rick Wakeman Live in Concert 2000 CD 1
The Sailor's Lament from Sea Airs 1
The Seventh Dimension from 2000AD Into The Future 1
The Shoot from White Rock 1
The Siege from Chronicles of Man 1
The Sleeping Child from Night Airs 1
The Stalker from Retro 1
The Suicide Shuffle from Wakeman with Wakeman 1
The Voyage of Ulysses from A Suite of Gods 1
Theme From The Burning from The Burning (Film Soundtrack) 1
Variations on the Fire from The Burning (Film Soundtrack) 1
Waveform from Retro 1
Wondrous Stories from The Piano Album 1
You Can't Buy Me Love from Phantom Power 1
Your Move from The Yes Piano Variations 1
You've Got To Hide Your Love Away from Tribute 1